Monument Grill vs Char Broil isn’t a fight with one clear winner. Char-Broil is the older, more familiar name with a very wide range of models, while Monument Grills is the newer brand that shoppers usually weigh on features for the money. The better grill is whichever specific model has the burners, build and warranty you actually need.
This guide shows you how to compare the two brands model against model, which specs deserve your attention, and where each brand tends to fit. We’ve also added two grills from other brands so you have a yardstick to measure against. HomeWhisk is a research team, so you won’t find hands-on cooking claims here. What you will find is a checklist you can run on any spec sheet before you spend a dollar.
Monument Grill vs Char Broil: the short version
Start with what you’re shopping for. Char-Broil sells everything from small charcoal grills to large gas cabinets, so the name alone tells you very little about quality or features. Monument Grills has a narrower lineup, and most people meet it through a single model that caught their eye. Neither brand name is a guarantee. The model is what counts.
Because both brands cover more than one price tier, compare a specific Monument model to a specific Char-Broil model at the same price. A $300 grill from one brand and a $600 grill from the other isn’t a fair match. Put them side by side on the same budget and the differences show up fast. If you haven’t settled on a number yet, our guides to the best grill under $300 and the best grill under $400 are a good place to anchor your search.
One more thing before the details. Brand loyalty can cloud a simple decision. Plenty of buyers pick Char-Broil because it’s the name they grew up with, and plenty pick Monument because the feature list looked generous. Both are fine reasons to start looking. Neither is a reason to stop reading the spec sheet.
Use a 6-burner gas grill as your benchmark
A reference point makes spec sheets easier to read. The Royal Gourmet below isn’t a Monument or a Char-Broil, so treat it as an alternative and a yardstick, not a stand-in for either brand. Its SG6002R is listed as a 6-burner propane grill with a sear burner and a side burner, in a stainless steel cabinet style, with 71,000 BTU output. That’s the kind of feature set you’ll run into on larger models from many brands.
Here’s how to use it. If a Monument or Char-Broil model you like has fewer burners, ask yourself whether you truly need the extra cooking surface. If it lists a bigger BTU number, ask whether that comes from more burners or from hotter ones. Spreading 71,000 BTU across six burners gives roughly 11,800 BTU each, though sear and side burners are often rated separately, so treat that as a rough guide only. Still, it gives you a number to compare against.

Royal Gourmet
Backyard Grilling for 8 to 10 Guests: Royal Gourmet SG6002R 6-Burner Propane Grill, 71,000 BTU, 714 sq. in. Cooking Area
The Royal Gourmet SG6002R spreads 71,000 BTU across five main burners, a sear burner, and a side burner, giving you 714 square inches of grate space and enough heat to cook proteins and sides at the same time. Buy it if you host groups of eight to ten and want searing, indirect cooking, and sauce work handled on one stainless cabinet grill.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- 71,000 BTU spread across seven burner outputs delivers real searing heat rather than a slow, uneven warm-up.
- Stainless steel upper lid, control panel, and cabinet doors hold up to weather better than painted steel and retain heat for roasts.
- The enclosed cabinet with storage basket and interior hook keeps grill tools and accessories protected between cooks.
- The 193 square inch warming rack holds finished food while the rest of the meal comes off the primary grates.
Cons
- Assembly covers a large multi-piece cabinet frame, so plan for a long build and a second set of hands before the first cook.
- One lid-mounted thermometer reads a 521 square inch primary surface, so an instant-read or probe thermometer is worth adding for zone cooking.
Royal Gourmet Backyard Grilling for 8 to 10 Guests: Royal Gourmet SG6002R 6-Burner Propane Grill, 71,000 BTU, 714 sq. in. Cooking Area

Royal Gourmet
Backyard Grilling for 8 to 10 Guests: Royal Gourmet SG6002R 6-Burner Propane Grill, 71,000 BTU, 714 sq. in. Cooking Area
The Royal Gourmet SG6002R spreads 71,000 BTU across five main burners, a sear burner, and a side burner, giving you 714 square inches of grate space and enough heat to cook proteins and sides at the same time. Buy it if you host groups of eight to ten and want searing, indirect cooking, and sauce work handled on one stainless cabinet grill.
$397.99 at AmazonEditors' Favorite
Color: Silver Size: Gas Grill Dimensions: 22.05 x 22.05 x 45.67 inches Weight: 92.5 pounds Product Group: Lawn & Patio Binding: Lawn & Patio
Shop NowHow to compare the two brands model by model
Pull up the listing for each grill and read it the same way every time. Work through the same questions in the same order, and write the answers down if it helps. A side-by-side note takes five minutes and saves you from buying on a hunch.
Burners and BTU
Burner count tells you how many heat zones you can set up. Two or three burners are enough for most weeknight cooking. Four or more lets you run one side hot and the other side low, which matters for thick cuts and for keeping food warm. BTU is the other half of the story. A common rule of thumb is roughly 80 to 100 BTU per square inch of primary cooking area. If a listing doesn’t state the cooking area, ask why.
A big BTU number on its own means less than people think. A grill that leaks heat through thin walls or loose lid seams can waste much of what it burns. That’s why the build matters just as much as the headline figure.
Materials and cabinet
Read what the listing says about the body, the lid, the grates and the cabinet. Stainless steel, painted steel and aluminum all behave differently over several seasons outdoors. Cast iron and porcelain-coated grates hold and release heat in different ways, and they need different care. If the listing is vague about materials, assume the answer isn’t flattering and compare accordingly.
Weight is a clue too. Heavier lids and thicker panels usually hold heat better, though a listing weight only helps when both brands publish one. Look for it. Compare it if you can find it.
Warranty and parts
Every grill eventually needs a new igniter, a new burner or a fresh set of grates. Check the warranty length on each part, not just the headline period, and see how easy replacements are to find. An older brand often has a bigger aftermarket of parts and accessories, which is one reason many shoppers lean toward Char-Broil. A newer brand may offer longer coverage on some parts to win your trust. Read both warranties in full. Don’t assume.
Gas or charcoal changes the whole comparison
Before you compare brands, decide on fuel. Propane gives you quick starts and steady control, so it suits weeknight cooking. Charcoal takes longer to light and rewards patience with smoky flavor. A gas model and a charcoal model from two different brands can’t be compared on burners at all, so make sure you’re matching like with like. Our guides to the best charcoal grill and the best portable grill cover both ends of that choice.
Sometimes the honest answer is that you don’t need a full-size grill from either brand. If your real goal is a cheap, small charcoal setup for camping, a beach day or a balcony, a compact model may fit better. The Uten folding charcoal grill below is another alternative that isn’t made by Monument or Char-Broil. It’s a tabletop design listed at 17 x 11.6 x 2.6 inches, built for camping, picnics, gardens and beach parties. That footprint points to a small cooking surface. Great for a couple of burgers. Not for a family cookout.

Uten
Portable Tabletop Charcoal Grilling for Camping, Picnics and Beach Parties: Uten Folding BBQ Smoker Grill, 17 x 11.6 x 2.6 Inch Stainless Steel
The Uten folding charcoal grill puts a 17 by 11.6 inch stainless steel cooking surface on any tabletop, with legs that rotate flat so the whole unit stows in a car trunk or backpack. Buy it if you cook for three to seven people away from a kitchen and want real charcoal flavor without hauling a full-size kettle.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Folded footprint and light stainless build make it realistic to carry to a park, beach, or campsite on foot.
- Unfolded legs brace the body in a triangular stance, which keeps it steady on picnic tables and uneven ground.
- Dual side vents give you actual control over burn rate instead of guesswork.
- Removable rack and dedicated charcoal groove keep ash contained and washing simple.
Cons
- The 2.6 inch depth limits charcoal capacity, so long cooks need a mid session refuel rather than one loaded burn.
- There is no lid, which rules out closed roasting and makes real smoking difficult despite the smoker label.
Uten Portable Tabletop Charcoal Grilling for Camping, Picnics and Beach Parties: Uten Folding BBQ Smoker Grill, 17 x 11.6 x 2.6 Inch Stainless Steel

Uten
Portable Tabletop Charcoal Grilling for Camping, Picnics and Beach Parties: Uten Folding BBQ Smoker Grill, 17 x 11.6 x 2.6 Inch Stainless Steel
The Uten folding charcoal grill puts a 17 by 11.6 inch stainless steel cooking surface on any tabletop, with legs that rotate flat so the whole unit stows in a car trunk or backpack. Buy it if you cook for three to seven people away from a kitchen and want real charcoal flavor without hauling a full-size kettle.
$20.89 at AmazonEditors' Favorite
Color: Black Size: 17.5" x 12.4" Dimensions: 17.52 x 12.4 x 2.95 Inches Weight: 2.97 Pounds Product Group: Home Improvement Binding: Tools & Home Improvement
Shop NowCommon mistakes when comparing grill brands
The most common slip is comparing across price tiers. A budget model from one brand will lose to a premium model from the other almost every time, and that tells you nothing about the brands. Match the budget first, then compare the features.
The second slip is trusting BTU alone. Burner count, cooking area, lid fit and wall thickness all change how that heat gets used. A modest BTU rating on a well-built grill can outcook a big number on a leaky one.
Third, buyers forget the extras. A cover, a set of tools, a propane tank and a good set of grill mats can add real money to the bill. Add those costs to each option before you decide which one is cheaper. Some listings include a few of them and some include none.
Finally, don’t lean too hard on star ratings. A high rating from a handful of reviews says less than a slightly lower rating from thousands. Check how many people rated the grill, then read the lowest-rated reviews for patterns such as rusting, hard-to-light burners or missing parts.
When to look beyond both brands
If the models you pull up don’t have what you need, widen the search. Plenty of good grills come from other makers, and a short list of three or four candidates beats a head-to-head between just two. If you’re willing to spend a little more, our best grill for $500 roundup shows what that extra money tends to buy.
Walk away from any model where the listing leaves out burner count, material or warranty details. A seller proud of the product tells you what’s in it. Missing details are a flag.
Also think about where the grill will live. A grill on a small patio needs clearance from walls and railings, and a cabinet-style gas model needs room for a propane tank. Measure the space first. Then measure the grill.
FAQ
Is a Monument grill better than a Char-Broil?
Neither brand wins across the board. Both sell several models at different prices, so the answer depends on the exact grill. Compare burners, cooking area, materials and warranty on two models at the same price, and pick the one that gives you more of what you’ll use.
Which brand is easier to find parts for?
An older brand like Char-Broil often has a larger supply of replacement parts and accessories. That’s a general pattern, not a guarantee for every model. Before you buy, search for the burner, igniter and grate for the exact model number you’re considering.
How many BTU do I need?
A common rule of thumb is roughly 80 to 100 BTU per square inch of primary cooking area. Use it as a rough check, not a rule. A well-built grill that holds heat can do more with fewer BTU than a poorly sealed one.
Are the Royal Gourmet and Uten grills on this page made by Monument or Char-Broil?
No. Both come from other brands. The Royal Gourmet 6-burner propane model and the Uten folding charcoal grill are here as alternatives and reference points, not as products from either brand in the title.
Should I buy a gas grill or a charcoal grill?
Pick gas if you want fast starts and easy temperature control for regular cooking. Pick charcoal if you enjoy the smoky flavor and don’t mind the extra time to light and clean up. Small tabletop charcoal grills also work well for camping and trips where a full-size grill won’t fit.

Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!